Build an interview scoring rubric
Fixes what you are scoring before the interview so you do not hire on impression.
| Category | Office work › HR & hiring |
|---|---|
| Tags | Question generationReviewingOffice worker |
Build an interview rubric. Per requirement: 1. **The question** that surfaces it. Ask about a specific past instance, not about general approach. *"How do you usually handle X" invites a rehearsed answer; "tell me about the last time X happened" does not.* 2. **The follow-up** that separates someone who did it from someone who watched it happen. 3. **What each level sounds like** — write a one-line example of a strong, adequate, and weak answer. Without these, scores drift between interviewers. 4. **The bar.** What is the minimum to pass on this requirement, and is it a hard gate or can it be traded against another strength? Then: - Time budget summing to the interview length, leaving room for their questions. - Which requirements this stage covers and which are left to another stage. *Trying to assess everything in one interview assesses nothing.* - **What NOT to score** — confidence, polish, similarity to the team, enthusiasm. Name these explicitly; they are what fills the gap when the rubric is thin. - One question that would reveal a serious mismatch early, to ask first. Rules: - *Do not include questions about personal circumstances, family, age, or anything unrelated to the work.* Flag any of mine that stray there. - Every question maps to a stated requirement. Drop the ones that do not. - Keep it to five or six requirements. More cannot be assessed in one sitting.
After pasting, fill in the fields at the bottom (Job requirements · Interview length · Stage)
What this prompt does
Without a rubric you hire whoever interviews well. This derives a probe and a bar per requirement, with examples of what each score looks like in an answer.