+ Provides the most specific and practical symptom, preparation, and tracking plan.
- It overstates that no emergency sign exists and adds an unnecessarily inferred date.
Names no condition, and stops to flag anything that could be urgent.
| Category | Life & health › Health records |
|---|---|
| Tags | ReformattingSummarizingQuestion generation |
**Open the output with this, written in the language you are answering in: "This is not medical advice and does not replace seeing a doctor."** ***Say it in the reader's language, not in English*** — **a disclaimer the reader skims past does nothing.** ⚠️ ***Before anything else: if what I describe could be urgent — chest pain, difficulty breathing, sudden severe pain, confusion, fainting, uncontrolled bleeding, a sudden change in vision or speech, or symptoms in an infant or a very old person — say to seek care now and stop. Do not continue organizing.*** Organize what I am experiencing into what a doctor will ask for. **In their order:** 1. **When it started** — ***a date or "about how long", not "recently"*** 2. **What it is** — ***in my own words first***, then the plainer description 3. **Where**, and whether it moves 4. **How it has changed** — better, worse, same, or coming and going. ***Over what period*** 5. **What makes it worse and what makes it better** 6. **What else changed around the same time** — sleep, eating, stress, travel, a new medication, a new activity 7. **What I have already tried**, and what happened 8. **Whether this has happened before** **Then:** - **What is missing from my account** that they will ask about. ***List as questions to me, not as assumptions*** - **What to bring** — records, a list of what I take, previous results - **What to record between now and the appointment** - ***How soon this should be seen***, only in terms of what I described — **and if I cannot tell from what I gave you, say to ask rather than wait** ⚠️ ***Do not name a condition. Do not say what it probably is or is not. Do not say it sounds minor. Do not suggest any medication, supplement, dose, or treatment.*** **If I ask you to guess a diagnosis, decline and say why.** ***This prompt organizes facts for a professional. That is the whole job.***
Symptoms get described badly not from poor memory but from order — doctors ask in a sequence patients do not use. This builds that sequence and returns the gaps as questions.
Claude is the most specific and practical, while ChatGPT is more concise and faithful. Gemini is well structured but adds an inference and misses required questions.
+ Provides the most specific and practical symptom, preparation, and tracking plan.
- It overstates that no emergency sign exists and adds an unnecessarily inferred date.
+ Follows the required order and turns missing details into useful questions.
- The urgency wording is somewhat vague, and the ending contains a foreign-language typo.
+ Turns the account into a clear, readable summary for a medical visit.
- It invents limited movement and omits several required lifestyle-change questions.
| Criterion | ChatGPT | Claude | Gemini | Leader |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instruction following | 9 | 9 | 7 | Tie |
| Accuracy | 9 | 8 | 7 | ChatGPT +13% |
| Specificity | 9 | 10 | 8 | Claude +11% |
| Structure | 9 | 10 | 9 | Claude +11% |
| Right length | 8 | 8 | 8 | Tie |
Scored 1–10 by gpt-5.6-sol with model names hidden (2026-09-24). This is an AI review, not a measurement.
We gave three models the same input and copied their answers unedited. Each ran in its CLI (an agent harness), and answers in the ChatGPT or Claude apps or on the web may differ. Outputs are in Korean.
What I am experiencing: 2주쯤 전부터 아침에 일어나면 오른쪽 어깨가 뻐근하다. 팔을 위로 들 때 특히 불편하고, 점심 지나면 좀 나아진다. 컴퓨터를 오래 보는 날에 더 심한 것 같다. 파스를 붙여봤는데 잘 모르겠다. How long: 2주
이 내용은 의학적 조언이 아니며, 의사의 진료를 대신하지 않습니다.
현재 적어주신 내용에서는 긴급 증상 여부를 판단할 정보가 충분하지 않습니다. 가슴 통증, 호흡 곤란, 실신, 갑작스러운 마비·말하기 변화 등이 있으면 지금 진료를 받으세요.
진료 때 추가로 물어볼 질문
가져갈 것
진료 전 기록할 것
진료 시기
약 2주째 지속되고 팔을 들 때 불편하므로 진료 예약을 문의해 보세요. 증상이 계속 악화되거나 팔의 힘·감각 변화, 심한 통증, 부기·열감이 생기면 기다리지 말고 진료를 받으세요. belirtilen 내용만으로 시기를 판단하기 어렵다면 의료기관에 문의해 확인하세요.
| ACLS Master Simulator | |
| Act as a Health Recovery and Weight Loss Specialist | |
| AI Assisted Doctor | |
| Bariatric ADHD Supplement Safety Plan. | |
| Coach for Identifying Growth-Limiting Patterns |